Seattle’s Best Hidden Pizza Gems Introduction
Seattle may be known for coffee and seafood, but its pizza scene is an underrated treasure trove of unique flavors and hidden gems. While big-name pizzerias often steal the spotlight, the city is home to incredible hole-in-the-wall spots and lesser-known joints serving up some of the best slices around. If you’re on the hunt for Seattle’s best hidden pizza gems, here are some must-visit locations:
1. Cornelly (Capitol Hill)
A true hidden gem on Capitol Hill, Cornelly takes a minimalist approach to pizza-making, focusing on high-quality ingredients and natural fermentation. Their thin, airy crust pairs beautifully with unique toppings like smoked ricotta and hot honey. Don’t skip their house-made soft-serve for dessert!
2. Dino’s Tomato Pie (Greenwood)
This unassuming dive-bar-style pizzeria serves up serious East Coast vibes with thick, crispy-bottomed Sicilian slices and classic Jersey-style pies. The dimly lit interior and jukebox make it the perfect late-night pizza destination. Try the Pepperoni & Pickled Peppers pie for a spicy kick.
3. Big Mario’s (Fremont, Queen Anne, & Capitol Hill)
While Big Mario’s has a few locations, their original Fremont spot maintains an old-school, no-frills charm that makes it feel like a hidden find. Their massive New York-style slices hit the spot after a night out, and their late-night hours make them a local favorite.
4. South Town Pie (South Park)
A little off the beaten path, South Town Pie in South Park is a must-visit for deep-dish lovers. Their buttery, crispy crust and rich tomato sauce make for a Chicago-style pie that rivals anything you’d find in the Midwest. The Soppressata & Hot Honey is a perfect blend of sweet and spicy.
5. Bar Del Corso (Beacon Hill)
While technically more of a trattoria than a pizzeria, Bar Del Corso serves up some of the best Neapolitan-style pies in the city. The wood-fired oven creates a perfectly blistered crust, and their Margherita pizza is simplicity at its finest.
6. Proletariat Pizza (White Center)
Located in the up-and-coming White Center neighborhood, Proletariat Pizza is a family-friendly spot known for its thin-crust, tavern-style pizzas. The Baked Potato Pizza, featuring bacon, sour cream, and green onions, is a surprisingly delicious take on a classic comfort food.
7. Lupo (Fremont)
Lupo is an intimate, stylish pizzeria focused on naturally leavened sourdough crust and hyper-local ingredients. Their Clam Pie, made with fresh clams, garlic, and chili flakes, is a standout, offering a taste of the Pacific Northwest with an Italian twist.
8. Tavolàta Stone Way (Wallingford)
While known for pasta, Tavolàta’s Stone Way location has a secret weapon: an exceptional Roman-style pizza. Their Mortadella & Pistachio pizza is a sleeper hit, bringing rich and nutty flavors together on a perfectly crisp crust.
10. Moto Pizza (West Seattle & Belltown)
Moto Pizza operates on a pre-order-only basis, making it one of Seattle’s most elusive yet highly sought-after pizza experiences. Their square, caramelized-crust Detroit-style pies sell out weeks in advance, but the Uncle Jesse (a decadent white sauce pizza with truffle oil) is well worth the wait.
Final Slice
Seattle’s pizza scene is as diverse as the city itself, offering something for every kind of pizza lover. Whether you crave a classic New York slice, a gourmet sourdough creation, or a deep-dish masterpiece, these hidden gems prove that the best pizza often comes from unexpected places.
What’s your favorite underrated pizza spot in Seattle? Let us know in the comments!
Where to stay
Looking for the perfect place to stay? Book our Capitol Hill short-term rental, centrally located near Seattle’s top attractions. Book your stay today and make the most of your Seattle adventure!
View comments
+ Leave a comment